While I was writing the text above I went into my files and looked to see how the design process played out. Here are some of the early designs that Alex and I were looking at before we had to reel things back in.
I was brought in by a different Bon Appétit team years later to do design a new logotype to replace the one I designed in 2011. We went through the whole process and the logotype was finished, but it never made it into public view for some reason. The logotype I designed for the 2011 redesign lived for another four years. These big redesign projects are very tricky.